I thought this Twitter thread was interesting. Low Tech Combat asked, “Who thinks "Aliveness" is not important?” To which Jason Crouch of The Martial Explorer answered, “what is aliveness.” My reply was:
tdatraining RT @jessecrouch: @lowtechcombat what is aliveness- Great question! Is it rhetorical? I will answer anyway: There is no hard and fast definition, like most things in martial arts, unless you isolate it to a particular system, e.g. JKD. It may be easier to define by asking what is dead in MA? Most think that a "dead" drill is one where the feeder, for ex, is not responding, but simply feeding an attack or responding with a defense without thought or emotion. He may as well be a machine.
An "alive" drill may be closer to sparring, in that a partner gives feedback or resistance. Is it important? Yes, of course it's important, but the "dead" is important too, because it develops basics, skills, and tactics and "aliveness" when learning something new can actually be detrimental to developing a technique or skill before the correct time. Does that make sense? I know their are lots of other perspectives and would love to hear them.
Being the expert researcher I am, I used the search term “aliveness,” and found this video on YouTube. Watch.
What do you think?
5 comments:
I think his boxers look fabulous with that shirt!
I think both are necessary. The static drills to get the basic technique correct, and the 'aliveness' to put it all together.
That being said, Aliveness is definitely a huge aspect of learning martial arts properly.
I think that 1) you may have combined Jesse's name and mine, and 2) it's largely a false dichotomy- even the SBG guys don't teach the basic mechanics of punching with someone punching back at you.
But bringing up the topic of aliveness and sparring in general does have my thoughts swirling, so I'll have to think a bit and put pen to paper. Well, at least fingers to keyboard.
@Jason
Oh dude, that's weird. Our names are rather close.
WRT aliveness - I think both are important and agree with Nathan's assessment.
Agree that both are important and useful.
I always learn something from your posts.
Thanks.
Post a Comment
Comments are usually moderated within 24 hours. Please be patient. You may also email comments to me at the link on the sidebar. Replies usually within 24 hours.
- Nathan